The Tijuana River has long been a source of contention for residents of the South Bay. On November 20, 2026 the stark reality of the sewage crisis was evident, with signs reading “TJ River Stench” marking areas where scientists detected high levels of hydrogen sulfide gas just south of Berry Elementary in San Ysidro.
For years, the South Bay International Wastewater Treatment Plant was managed by Veolia Water West Operating Services, Inc. under a substantial federal contract. However, the company’s alleged failures in maintenance and operations have led to severe consequences for the community.
The Human Impact of the Sewage Crisis
Kristin Westphal a trial attorney and resident of Imperial Beach has witnessed firsthand the devastating effects of the sewage crisis. Like many South Bay residents, she has experienced the foul odors, health concerns, and economic losses resulting from the contamination. Westphal is now representing victims of the crisis, seeking both meaningful repairs and accountability.
The crisis has led to frequent beach closures diminished property values, and a significant decline in the quality of life for South Bay residents. The economic impact is substantial, with the community bearing the brunt of the costs while Veolia continues to receive public funds.
The Role of Litigation in Seeking Accountability
Some argue that litigation against Veolia hinders efforts to fix the sewage crisis. However, Westphal contends that this perspective is not supported by the facts. The funding for necessary repairs comes from federal appropriations and infrastructure investments, not from Veolia’s pockets.
“Lawsuits do not prevent repairs. They create accountability.” Westphal asserts. Litigation serves as a crucial tool for ordinary citizens when powerful entities fail to fulfill their legal obligations. The increased public scrutiny and accelerated efforts toward repairs began only after multiple lawsuits were filed against those alleged to be responsible.
The purpose of these lawsuits is not to halt progress but to ensure that companies and entities alleged to have harmed the community are held responsible if the evidence establishes liability. A repaired plant does not erase years of exposure, nor does new infrastructure undo the negative health impacts and economic losses that residents have suffered.
The Need for Transparency and Justice
South Bay residents have been promised solutions for decades, yet the contamination persists. Westphal emphasizes the importance of transparency and accountability from those who were paid to protect the community. The current situation is the result of decisions made and responsibilities not met, and litigation is one way to ensure those found responsible answer for their actions.
Veolia denies responsibility and has disputed allegations of wrongdoing. However, it is the courts who will ultimately determine the merits of the claims. South Bay residents deserve clean air, clean water, functioning infrastructure—and justice.
As the legal battle unfolds, the community remains hopeful that their voices will be heard and that meaningful change will come. The fight for accountability in the Tijuana sewage crisis is far from over, but with advocates like Kristin Westphal, the South Bay residents are taking a stand for their rights and their future.
