On a recent Thursday, an eight-year-old Haitian boy attending Fay Elementary School in the Colina del Sol neighborhood was taken into ICE custody after an immigration check. The episode sparked an immediate response from the San Diego congressional delegation, who sent letters to the secretaries of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) demanding answers.
Legislators raise concerns over the child’s treatment
Representatives Juan Vargas, Sara Jacobs, Scott Peters and Mike Levin drafted the letters to DHS secretary Mullin and HHS secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.. They were joined by Senators Alex Padilla and Adam Schiff. The lawmakers described video footage that appears to show the child being restrained despite showing no threatening behavior. They wrote, “The images raise serious doubts about the handling of this incident and the potential harm to a young child who complied with a required immigration hearing.”
The delegation emphasized that “the safety and wellbeing of children and families in San Diego County must remain the top priority,” and asked for confirmation of the child’s location, whether his family knows where he is, and what steps agencies are taking to reunite him with his relatives.
ICE’s response and the legal backdrop
ICE issued a detailed statement rejecting the allegation that agents detained a third-grader for custody. The agency called the claim “false” and framed any contrary suggestion as an attempt to disparage ICE officers and undermine the policies of former President Trump and Secretary Mullin. According to ICE, a man claiming to be the child’s uncle escorted him to the immigration interview but could not prove legal guardianship under the 2008 anti-trafficking law. Consequently, officials classified the boy as an unaccompanied foreign minor and placed him under the care of the Refugee Resettlement Office.
ICE also noted that the boy originally entered the United States with a man who identified himself as his father; that adult was later deported to Mexico by Customs and Border Protection. The agency’s explanation underscores the complex legal criteria that must be met for a relative to assume custody of a minor in immigration proceedings.
Broader context: minors’ arrests in San Diego and Imperial counties
Data from the non-profit Deportation Data Project reveal that detentions of children are not isolated events in the region. Between the inauguration of President Trump in January 2025 and August 2026, at least 760 minors were apprehended by Immigration agents in San Diego and Imperial counties. Of those, 267 were ten years of age or younger.
Nearly 200 of the detained children were placed in a detention facility after their arrests, and dozens remained behind bars for months, violating the Flores Settlement Agreement that caps the detention of minors at 20 days. The nearest holding center for youths is the South Texas Family Residential Center in Dilley, Texas, where parents and children share communal cells. Congressional investigations earlier this year uncovered deficiencies in access to clean water, medical care, and education at that site.
School district reaction and the impact on education
The following day, the San Diego Unified School District (SDUSD) demanded clarification about the student’s whereabouts. District officials said they had received a letter inviting a meeting with an ICE agent. The child’s uncle, who has cared for him since his father’s deportation over a year ago, accompanied him to the interview to avoid any legal violation.
SDUSD superintendent Fabi Bagula and other district leaders wrote their own letters to Mullin and Kennedy, stressing that children should not bear the educational fallout of political decisions beyond their control. “When families are separated, displaced, detained, or abruptly expelled, schools are forced to address the resulting trauma and disruption,” the district wrote. “These circumstances expose children to significant academic regression, mental-health challenges, and long-term instability.”
Legal status of Haitian immigrants and recent policy shifts
The boy’s case is further complicated by the expiration of the Temporary Protected Status (TPS) for Haitian nationals on July 27. The Supreme Court’s decision in June affirmed that the Trump administration could suspend legal protections for thousands of Haitians and Syrians. More than 350,000 Haitians reside in the United States, many of whom arrived following the 2010 earthquake that initially prompted the Obama administration to grant TPS.
Haiti’s recent history includes decades of authoritarian rule, a series of contested elections, and a lingering crisis that began in 2018, driving over 600,000 Haitians to displacement and prompting a wave of migration to the United States. The political rhetoric surrounding Haitian migrants has been hostile; former President Trump repeatedly used derogatory language to describe the community, intensifying public debate over immigration enforcement.
As the San Diego delegation awaits a response, the case underscores the tension between immigration enforcement, child-welfare protections, and the obligations of local schools to safeguard student education amid federal actions.



