On August 15, 2016 a California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation officer unlocked the gate at San Quentin State Prison’s exercise yard, a scene that would later contrast sharply with a sweeping clemency move by Governor Gavin newsom. Earlier this year the governor announced a blanket commutation of every death-row sentence in the state, affecting 548 inmates, and ordered the dismantling of the execution chamber at San Quentin. The decision reignited a debate over the balance of executive power, statutory victim-notification requirements, and the future of the death penalty in California.
In a petition filed on November 16, 2026, district attorneys from thirty California counties teamed up with an advocacy organization for crime victims to ask the California Supreme court to intervene. The filing contends that Newsom’s unilateral action violated a penal-code provision that obligates a governor to notify the district attorney in the county where the crime occurred and to give victims or their families an opportunity to be heard. The petitioners quote their own language: “Only this court can stop the governor’s disregard of the law — his abuse of power.”
Prosecutors and victims’ groups file lawsuit
The coalition of prosecutors argues that the law’s notification requirement is not optional, even when a commutation is issued without a formal inmate application. Under California statutes, a condemned prisoner who requests clemency triggers a process that includes informing the victims’ families. By proposing a blanket commutation, the governor sidestepped that procedural safeguard, the petitioners say, thereby infringing on victims’ statutory rights.
Representatives of the victims’ organization emphasized the democratic context, noting that California voters have twice reaffirmed support for the death penalty. “California voters have twice voted to retain the death penalty,” said Mary Muscarella, whose son was murdered in 1990. The lawsuit therefore seeks to enforce the legal framework that balances executive mercy with the voices of those harmed.
Governor’s legal justification and procedural steps
Governor Newsom responded by arguing that the penal-code language cited by the plaintiffs does not apply when the governor acts on his own initiative, absent a formal inmate request. In a written explanation he stated that the statute “does not apply when the governor acts on his own initiative to grant clemency absent an application.” He added that, after submitting the commutation list to the Supreme Court, his office would contact the relevant district attorneys and request their assistance in notifying victims.
The governor also distinguished his power from the presidential pardon authority, which lacks comparable procedural limits. By contrast, California law creates a specific pathway that includes victim notification, a step Newsom claims is bypassed only because the commutations were not prompted by inmate petitions.
Implications for the death-penalty system
State law mandates that the California Supreme Court review any commutation involving multiple felonies, a category that includes roughly 400 of the 548 cases. The court has not yet disclosed a timetable for those reviews, leaving the ultimate fate of the remaining inmates uncertain.
Newsom’s 2019 moratorium on executions and the subsequent removal of the death-row facility at San Quentin marked a significant shift in California’s capital-punishment landscape. The incoming governor, Xavier becerra, has pledged to extend that moratorium, signaling a potential long-term cessation of state-sanctioned executions. Nonetheless, voices such as Kate Chatfield, executive director of the California Public Defender’s Association, remind observers that “not all families of victims believe in the death penalty” and that the state has not carried out an execution since 2006.
Should the Supreme Court uphold the petition, the decision could reaffirm the procedural rights of victims and set a precedent limiting the scope of gubernatorial clemency. Conversely, a ruling in favor of the governor would cement the authority to grant sweeping commutations without the traditional notification process, reshaping the balance between executive discretion and victim participation in California’s criminal-justice system.



